This is a list originally compiled by Rufhelous and since has been added on by me (Kraelyst). Rufhelous did some testing and found that learning is best when juggling 6 to 9 items (whenever you get the 14 second RT). Therefore if you're juggling 5 or less you need to move down in weight and if you are juggling 8 or 9 you should move up in weight. If you're juggling 6 or 7 you're just right!

     
Wt Juggling Item Location/Origin
1
 colorful beanbags Aesry Puzzle Shop
1
 colorful balls Amusement Pier Clown
1
 [etched/rough/small/detailed] [pewter/glass/driftwood/oak/cedar/silverwood/ebony/rosewood] [yaks/skulls/eyeballs/stars/spheres/cubes/eggs/rosebuds]
Example: some etched pewter yaks		 Amusement Pier Clown
1
 miniature wooden barrel Amusement Pier Clown
1
 shrunken kobold heads Corik's Quest end prize
1
 multi-hued juggling scarves Trader Fest
1
 multi-hued silk diamonds Trader Fest
1
 colorful gypsy scarves Wren Fest
1
 jade-colored balls Mentor Prize
1
 small glass dragons unknown
1
 colorful rock troll beanbags Taisidon Safari
1
 colorful goblin beanbags 1st Jaal Jeraya Fest
1
 colorful madmen beanbags 1st Jaal Jeraya Fest
1
 giant juggling taffelberries 1st Jaal Jeraya Fest
1
 plush black panthers with green button eyes Shard Outcast Fest & Merelew II (Thief shop)
     
2
[crimson/lime/tan/mauve/chipped/cracked/dull] [pottery/clay/basalt/deobar/oak/pine] [tiles/squares]
Example: some crimson pottery tiles		 Throne City Museum/Excavation
2
[orange/green/gold/beige] mosaic tiles Throne City Museum/Excavation
     
3
colorful fabric butterflies Rossman's Landing
3
brightly-scaled cobras with tiny leather hoods Shard Outcast Fest & Merelew II (Thief shop)
     
5
aether spheres Warrior Mage Aether Cantrip
5
[clay/sandstone] pottery fragments Throne City Museum/Excavation
5
handful of rusted nails Throne City Museum/Excavation
5
fuzzy hamsters Aesry Puzzle Shop
5
small stuffed foxes embroidered with the symbol of the Order of the Black Fox Order Social Night
5
jagged silver shark teeth 2nd Jaal Jeraya Fest
5
beaded toebones Shard Outcast Fest
5
plush brown shrikes with tiny beaks Shard Outcast Fest & Merelew II (Thief shop)
5
tiny silver tarts embedded with round cambrinth stones Merelew II
     
7
bleached and shrunken baby yak skulls Old Thief Shop
     
10
vivid silk ladybugs Rossman's Landing
10
set of onyx dragons Amusement Pier Clown
10
grinning dragon beanbags Taisidon Safari
10
bamboo sticks Taisidon Safari
10
stuffed dragons Taisidon Safari
10
set of multi-colored dragons Taisidon Safari
10
a bunch of worthless contracts Old Thief Shop
10
polished ivory fisheads 2nd Jaal Jeraya Fest
10
mammoth anklebones Shard Outcast Fest
10
darkly-scaled adders with pink felt tongues Shard Outcast Fest & Merelew II (Thief shop)
10
wide etched silver rings studded with cambrinth Merelew II
10
rope knots Merelew II
10
painted wooden gemstones Merelew II
     
12
stuffed crosseyed gerbils Old Thief Shop
12
stuffed baby raccoons unknown
     
15
satin clowns Aesry Puzzle Shop
15
medium stuffed foxes embroidered with the symbol of the Order of the Black Fox Order Social Night
15
solid bronze acorns 2nd Jaal Jeraya Fest
15
leaded fingerbones Shard Outcast Fest
15
fuzzy brown shrews with long leather tails Shard Outcast Fest & Merelew II (Thief shop)
15
tiny pewter shields emblazoned with the cambrinth-studded crest of the Warrior Mage guild Merelew II
     
20
dusky blue wooden crabs Rossman's Landing
20
engraved silver globes Amusement Pier Clown
20
set of crystal balls 1st Jaal Jeraya Fest
20
carved ironwood chickens Premium Sea Caves Gift
20
set of leather-wrapped stilettos (weighs 20, but teaches much higher) Blacklark and Fandella's Wedding
20
carved amber pinecones 2nd Jaal Jeraya Fest
20
metal-studded ulnas Shard Outcast Fest
20
some bright blue fuzzy sharks with pointy leather teeth Shard Outcast Fest & Merelew II (Thief shop)
20
shapeless bronze talismans studded evenly with small cambrinth stones Merelew II
20
heavy rope knots Merelew II
     
25
brightly painted wooden oranges Aesry Puzzle Shop
25
miniature rounded tin helms Warrior Mage Fest
25
silvery silk stars Trader Fest
25
oversized silver kronars Trader Fest
25
oversized gold lirums Trader Fest
25
oversized platinum dokoras Trader Fest
25
fuzzy baby yaks Trader Fest
25
green leather toads Trader Fest
25
miniature roan horse Trader Fest
25
old shoes Trader Fest
25
miniature leather-bound books Trader Fest
25
stuffed white feathered chickens Trader Fest
25
red wooden apples Trader Fest
25
fuzzy turnips Trader Fest/Wren Fest
25
ivory skulls Wren Fest
25
miniature iron juggling tankards Wren Fest
25
miniature oak juggling kegs Wren Fest
25
miniature pirate ships 1st Jaal Jeraya Fest
25
patinated copper clovers 2nd Jaal Jeraya Fest
25
polished conch shells Taisidon Safari
25
green juggling coconuts Taisidon Safari
25
large stuffed foxes embroidered withthe symbol of the Order of the Black Fox Order Social Night
25
carved shoulder blades Shard Outcast Fest
25
lead-wrapped kneecaps Shard Outcast Fest
25
beady-eyed stuffed weasels with furry tails Shard Outcast Fest & Merelew II (Thief shop)
25
crimson-hued fireballs trailing carved cambrinth flames Merelew II
     
30
carved ebonwood beetles Rossman's Landing
30
large glass peaches Amusement Pier Clown
30
blackened steel twigs 2nd Jaal Jeraya Fest
30
brass-tipped rib bones Shard Outcast Fest
30
plush heron chicks with dangling felt legs Shard Outcast Fest & Merelew II (Thief shop)
30
polished silver lightning bolts tipped with cambrinth Merelew II
     
35
carved oak rings Aesry Puzzle Shop
35
petrified vertebrae Shard Outcast Fest
35
plush goshawk chicks with long grey feathers Shard Outcast Fest & Merelew II (Thief shop)
35
burnished gold spheres set with flame-shaped cambrinth stones Merelew II
     
40
bright red wooden lobsters Rossman's Landing
40
shiny golden crowns Amusement Pier Clown
40
tiny polished shields 1st Jaal Jeraya Fest
40
thick femurs fitted with iron banding Shard Outcast Fest
40
scraggly-feathered vultures with long carved beaks Shard Outcast Fest & Merelew II (Thief shop)
40
twisted ironwood wands tipped with pear-shaped cambrinth stones Merelew II
40
iron belaying pins Merelew II
     
45
miniature hand-axes Aesry Puzzle Shop
45
set of heavy ironwood dragons Taisidon Safari
45
heavy basilisk jawbones Shard Outcast Fest
45
coiled ebonwood vipers with glittering garnet eyes Shard Outcast Fest & Merelew II (Thief shop)
45
sapphire-studded cambrinth swords Merelew II
     
50
striped juggling pins Aesry Puzzle Shop
50
dark green frogs Amusement Pier Clown
50
rough juggling clubs Warrior Mage Fest
50
steel-capped skulls Shard Outcast Fest
50
bronze-inlaid pelvises Shard Outcast Fest
50
carved bloodwood centaurs with tiny onyx hooves Shard Outcast Fest & Merelew II (Thief shop)
50
gem-encrusted platinum dragons set with sparkling cambrinth teardrops Merelew II
50
small anchors Merelew II
50
oversized lockpicks Merelew II
     
60
 battered rum bottles Ghost Ship end prize
70
pewter-handled hammers 1st Jaal Jeraya Fest
75
set of rusted hand scythes covered in cobwebs Pre-Web Party at Winthoren Manor